Small Building, Big Potential: Adaptive Reuse in the Aberdeen Architectural Conservation District

At its August 13, 2026 hearing, the Aberdeen Architectural Conservation District Commission (AACDC) approved a small project with big potential for a quiet corner of the neighborhood.

Tucked between an Art Deco apartment building dating to 1929 and a stone-clad Arts and Crafts house from 1910, 2 Egremont Road (also known as 53-55 Cummings Road) is a modest industrial structure that was likely constructed as a garage or maintenance shop serving one of the neighboring properties. It is not the sort of building that would typically command attention, but its utilitarian character provides an important reminder that historic neighborhoods have always been made up of buildings of different scales, styles, and uses.

Now, the building is being given a new life. The approved project will adapt the structure for two residential units while retaining and interpreting its industrial character. Working closely with Commission staff, the architects at Context Architects developed a design that makes relatively simple changes to accommodate a new use without erasing the building's history.

One of the most visible changes is a new, distinctly modern third floor added to the top of the existing structure. Rather than attempting to imitate the historic building, the addition clearly distinguishes new construction from the original. This approach reflects an important principle of historic preservation: a building does not always need to remain frozen in time to retain its historic character. In fact, carefully designed additions can demonstrate how a place continues to evolve.

The Aberdeen Architectural Conservation District Standards recognize that additions can sometimes be appropriate when they allow buildings to accommodate changing needs and uses. At the same time, those changes must respect the architectural integrity of the historic resource and the landscape that contributes to Aberdeen's distinctive neighborhood character. The project at 2 Egremont Road illustrates how those goals can work together.

The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Additions to Historic Buildings provide a useful framework for this approach. New work should preserve significant historic materials and features; be distinguishable from the original building; remain compatible in massing, scale, and architectural character; avoid creating a false sense of history; and, where possible, be designed so that it can be removed without impairing the essential form and integrity of the historic resource.

At 2 Egremont Road, these principles are reflected in the details. The former garage door openings are being transformed into windows that retain the visual language and proportions of an industrial door. New materials and finishes draw inspiration from the building's utilitarian past without pretending to be historic. The modern upper story makes no attempt to disguise its date of construction. Together, these interventions allow the building's past and present to remain legible.

Perhaps most importantly, the project demonstrates why adaptive reuse matters even when the building itself may not be considered architecturally significant. Historic preservation is not solely about protecting exceptional individual buildings. It is also about retaining the layers of history that give neighborhoods their identity. A small garage, workshop, carriage house, or commercial building can reveal how a neighborhood operated and how its residents' needs changed over generations.

There is also an environmental argument for giving these buildings a second life. Every existing building contains embodied energy, which is the energy that was already expended to extract, manufacture, transport, and assemble its materials. Demolishing a building discards that investment while generating construction and demolition waste and requiring new materials to be produced and transported. Retaining and rehabilitating an existing structure, when feasible, extends the useful life of materials such as brick, timber, stone, and metal while avoiding some of the environmental costs associated with starting over.

Adaptive reuse can also make it possible to improve a building's energy performance without sacrificing its historic character. Air sealing, insulation, efficient mechanical systems, and other upgrades can reduce operational energy use while allowing significant historic features and materials to remain.

Historic preservation is often associated with grand houses, elaborate facades, and architecturally distinguished landmarks. But the character of a historic neighborhood is rarely defined by its most prominent buildings alone. Sometimes, the most unassuming structures tell an equally important story about how neighborhoods were built, how they functioned, and how they changed over time. The adaptive reuse of a small former industrial building at 2 Egremont Road offers a compelling example.

The story of 2 Egremont Road is therefore larger than the building itself. Its transformation from a modest industrial structure into housing demonstrates that preservation does not have to mean preventing change. Instead, preservation can provide a framework for managing change thoughtfully, allowing buildings to accommodate new uses while retaining the physical evidence of the uses and people that came before.

The result is a building that will look different in the future, but will still be able to tell its story. In a historic district, that may be one of the most important things a building can do.

To learn more about the district, including regulations and district boundaries click here.

This article was prepared by Nicholas Armata, Senior Preservation Planner.

• Published by: Landmarks Commission