721 Exchange vs 1031 Exchange

When an investor decides to sell an investment property without an immediate tax bill, the 721 exchange vs 1031 exchange decision is one of the most consequential they will make. Both structures defer capital gains and depreciation recapture, but they diverge sharply from there. A 1031 exchange preserves real estate ownership through property replacement, while a 721 exchange allows investors to defer taxes and transition into diversified, passive REIT ownership.

This piece compares the 721 exchange vs 1031 exchange across tax deferral, liquidity, ownership control, diversification, timing constraints, and long-term outcomes.

721 Exchange vs 1031 Exchange: Side-by-Side Comparison

The table below summarizes how the two structures differ across the factors that most affect long-term portfolio fit. Both defer the same taxes; the differences lie in what happens to ownership, liquidity, and flexibility afterward.

How a 1031 Exchange Works

A 1031 exchange lets an investor sell an investment property and reinvest the proceeds into a like-kind replacement property, deferring capital gains and depreciation recapture taxes. Full deferral requires reinvesting the entire proceeds into property of equal or greater value.

What "Like-Kind" Means

For real estate, "like-kind" refers to the nature of the asset, not its type. Any real property held for investment or business use qualifies as like-kind to any other. Asset class, quality, vintage, and location wouldn't disqualify a property from being like-kind.* What disqualifies a property is personal use or not being real estate.

Note: Since the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, 1031 treatment applies only to real property. Personal property, such as equipment and vehicles, no longer qualifies, and stocks, bonds, and REIT shares cannot be acquired through a 1031 exchange.

Best Suited For Investors Who:

• Want to remain invested in real estate, so they can continue to exchange
• Prefer to remain in control of day-to-day decision-making and management
• Are comfortable managing replacement property, or prefer a passive DST alternative
• Prefer to hold a single replacement property rather than a diversified portfolio
• Value the ability to repeat exchanges indefinitely

How a 721 Exchange (UPREIT) Works

A 721 exchange, which can also be referred to as a UPREIT transaction, allows an investor to contribute property into a real estate investment trust's operating partnership in exchange for operating partnership (OP) units, deferring capital gains and depreciation recapture taxes. Rather than owning a single replacement property, the investor holds a passive interest in the REIT's entire diversified portfolio.

Whether a property qualifies:

A REIT will only accept properties that meet its investment criteria, which in many cases are institutional-grade properties, such as larger multifamily communities or major commercial assets. Owners of qualifying property can contribute it directly to the operating partnership in exchange for OP units.

With that in mind, an investor who owns a multifamily property is generally best served by a multifamily-focused REIT, while an investor with an industrial property would look into an industrial-focused REIT, since the REIT must have an interest in acquiring that specific property through a 721 exchange.

An investor whose property does not meet those standards may instead complete a 1031 exchange into a DST, and separately, if that DST later offers an optional 721 exchange conversion, choose to contribute the DST interest into the REIT. Because that conversion cannot be promised or pre-arranged when the DST is acquired, each transaction stands on its own and must be made without a guarantee that the 721 exchange will occur.

Best suited for investors who:

• Want to transition out of active property management into passive ownership
• Seek diversification across a professionally managed portfolio rather than a single asset
• Value an eventual path to liquidity through REIT share conversion, subject to sponsor terms
• Are coordinating a real estate disposition with estate planning

Choosing Between a 721 Exchange and a 1031 Exchange

Both structures defer the same capital gains and depreciation recapture taxes, so the decision rarely comes down to tax deferral alone. It comes down to what an investor wants next.

A 1031 exchange keeps the door open for future exchanges and allows a property owner to remain as an active real estate manager. A 721 exchange offers a more permanent move to diversification, a path to liquidity (in whole or in part), and estate-planning flexibility.

Using both over time:

The two structures can also work in sequence. An investor may complete a 1031 exchange into a DST as a standalone investment held for income and tax deferral. Separately, if that DST later offers an optional 721 conversion, the investor can choose at that point to contribute to the REIT.

Because that conversion cannot be promised or pre-arranged when the DST is acquired, each transaction stands on its own. Investors should treat the two decisions independently and consult a tax advisor.

Choosing the Right Structure for Your Transaction

For property owners weighing a 721 exchange vs 1031 exchange, the right answer depends on details that are easy to underestimate: the size and quality of the property, the timing of the sale, debt that needs to be replaced, income needs during the hold, and how the asset should eventually pass to heirs. Each structure carries its own rules, deadlines, and irreversible decisions, and the wrong move can trigger the exact tax the transaction was meant to defer.

This is where guidance matters. Standardized 1031 and DST structures work well for many investors, but larger or more complex transactions often call for custom structuring, whether that means coordinating timing across multiple properties, addressing debt replacement, or aligning a real estate disposition with broader estate and wealth transfer planning.

Bonaventure offers 1031, DST, and 721 pathways within a single platform, along with custom structured solutions for transactions that do not fit a standard mold.

To discuss how these structures apply to a specific transaction,
speak with the Bonaventure team.

The article is for informational and educational purposes only and not intended to be all-inclusive and may be changed at any time without notice or obligation to update. The information contained herein does not constitute legal, compliance, tax, or financial advice. This communication is not a recommendation of any security, strategy, or service. Any such recommendation or solicitation would be made under separate cover.

*Third-Party Disclosure
The articles linked throughout were produced by independent third parties and should not be considered a solicitation or recommendation. Any such recommendation or solicitation would be made under separate cover. We do not endorse or accept responsibility for the content of any third-party website.

Footnotes
¹ For real estate, "like-kind" is broad: any property held for investment or business use qualifies as like-kind to any other, regardless of type. An apartment building is like-kind to raw land, retail, or industrial property. See IRS Fact Sheet FS-2008-18*.
² Full deferral requires acquiring replacement property of equal or greater value, reinvesting all net equity, and replacing any debt. Trading down in value or taking cash out creates "boot," which is subject to capital gains and depreciation recapture taxes.
³ Under IRC Section 721, no gain is recognized at contribution, and the property's basis carries over to the OP units. The deferred gain is preserved, not eliminated, and becomes taxable when OP units are sold or converted to REIT shares.
⁴ A direct 721 contribution has no IRS deadlines. The common DST-to-UPREIT path, however, generally involves holding the DST interest for a period (often two years or more) before the 721 contribution.
⁵ Conversion and redemption are typically subject to a 12-24 month holding period, quarterly volume caps, and sponsor or board discretion, and are not guaranteed. Converting OP units to REIT shares is a taxable event.
⁶ A step-up in basis at death is not automatic and depends on how the investment is held. Individually held and pass-through interests may receive a step-up, while entities such as C-corporations, S-corporations, and irrevocable trusts may not. Investors should consult their own tax advisor.