Insight Guru Inc.

11/19/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/19/2026 18:51

On IMF Numbers, Only France Fails Both Debt Tests

Today's big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?

Two simple tests show whether a government's debt will grow on its own. First, is the interest rate it pays below the economy's nominal growth, meaning growth before taking out inflation? Second, is its deficit small enough to hold debt flat as a share of GDP? We ran both tests on eight big borrowers, using the IMF's projections. On those numbers, only France fails both. That matters because bond investors have started to charge France more than Italy for 10-year money. The arithmetic says they have a point.

The Scorecard For Eight Big Borrowers

For nominal growth we added the IMF's 2026 projections for real growth and consumer inflation. The deficit that holds debt flat is roughly nominal growth times the debt ratio. The deficit column shows each government's overall 2026 deficit. All figures are % of GDP or % a year.

Country 10-year yield Nominal growth Deficit Deficit that holds debt flat Verdict
US 5.07 5.5 7.5 6.9 Fails deficit test
Japan 2.76 2.9 2.0 5.9 Passes both
Germany 3.42 3.5 3.8 2.3 Fails deficit test
France 4.89 2.7 4.9 3.2 Fails both
Italy 4.68 3.1 2.8 4.3 Fails rate test
UK 5.34 4.0 3.9 4.1 Fails rate test
Spain 4.07 5.1 2.1 5.0 Passes both
Canada 3.88 4.0 2.7 4.4 Passes both

Source: IMF World Economic Outlook, 2026 projections (October 2026 snapshot). Yields are October 2026 monthly averages from FRED. The US yield is the Nov. 18 close, because our data has no October average for it.

On the IMF's projections, France is the only one of the eight that fails both tests. Risks like that are easier to live with when part of your money is built to fall less. The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500's, and it lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018. See the metrics.

Why France Is The Row That Stands Out

In October, France paid an average of 4.89% to borrow for 10 years. Its nominal growth is about 2.7% under the IMF's projections. That is a gap of about 2.2 percentage points against France. Its deficit is 4.9% of GDP, while about 3.2% would hold its debt flat. The IMF projects French debt rising from 118.4% of GDP in 2026 to 121.2% in 2030.

Italy carries more debt, at 138.4% of GDP. But its deficit of 2.8% sits below the 4.3% that would hold its debt flat. The IMF sees Italian debt easing to 136.5% by 2030.

The bond market has moved the same way. At the end of 2012, France paid 2.5 percentage points less than Italy for 10-year money. By the end of 2024 that gap had shrunk to 0.3 points. By the end of 2025 it had reached zero. In October 2026, France paid 0.21 points more.

Two caveats apply. The 10-year yield is the cost of new borrowing, not the average rate on old debt. And consumer inflation is only a stand-in for the price measure used in GDP. So treat these tests as approximate.

The strongest counter is inflation. French inflation rose to 3.7% in October. If that pace held for a year, nominal growth would be about 4.6%. That is still below the 4.89% yield, so the rate test still fails. The deficit test would then pass, though. France fails both tests only on the IMF's lower inflation path.

Who Passes, And Who Else Fails

Japan, Spain and Canada pass both tests. Japan is the striking one. Its debt is 204.4% of GDP, the highest of the eight. But its 2.76% yield sits just under its 2.9% nominal growth, and its 2.0% deficit is far below the 5.9% that would hold debt flat. The IMF sees Japanese debt falling to 193.9% by 2030. Spain passes easily on 5.1% nominal growth.

The US fails the deficit test, with a 7.5% deficit against the 6.9% that would hold its debt flat. The IMF sees US debt rising from 125.8% to 138.9% of GDP by 2030. Germany also fails it, though from a low debt level of 64.6%. Italy and the UK fail the rate test instead: each pays more to borrow than its economy grows.

What This Means For Your Holdings

The tests matter differently depending on who controls the currency. The US, Japan, the UK and Canada borrow in money their own central banks issue. They can always pay. Their risk shows up instead as inflation, a weaker currency or a higher term premium. The term premium is the extra yield lenders demand to tie up money for longer. Owning its currency is why the US can always pay in dollars even while failing a test.

France, Italy, Germany and Spain borrow in euros, which the European Central Bank controls. France cannot print its way out. Its risk shows up as a wider spread, meaning the extra yield it pays over German bonds. That is closer to default-style risk.

US holders of French assets carry two risks. The first is that spread, which widens if lenders lose confidence in French finances. The second is the currency. The euro fell 4.31% against the dollar in the three months to Nov. 13, to $1.103.

When To Run The Test Again

The inputs change when the IMF publishes its next round of projections, when France sets its next budget, and each month as new yield averages arrive. For France, watch two things. If French inflation stays near October's 3.7%, it would pass the deficit test. To pass the rate test, its yield would need to fall, or its growth to rise, by about 2.2 points.

Germany is the row most likely to change. It already fails the deficit test, and its 3.42% yield is less than 0.1 points under its 3.5% nominal growth. If its yield rose above its nominal growth, Germany would join France in failing both tests. The UK is next. Its 3.9% deficit is about 0.2 points under the line. Canada and Japan sit within 0.15 points of failing the rate test.

In 2012, France paid 2.5 points less than Italy to borrow. By October 2026, it paid more. Few saw that shift coming, and no one can reliably predict the next one. A portfolio does not have to depend on calling it.

Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.

No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn't try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.

See How HQ Works

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.

Insight Guru Inc. published this content on November 19, 2026, and is solely responsible for the information contained herein. Distributed via Public Technologies (PUBT), unedited and unaltered, on November 20, 2026 at 00:51 UTC. If you believe the information included in the content is inaccurate or outdated and requires editing or removal, please contact us at [email protected]