Shasta County Man Sentenced to 30 Years in Prison for Running a $35 Million Investment Fraud Scheme and Witness Tampering

SACRAMENTO, Calif. - Matthew Piercey, 49, of Palo Cedro, was sentenced today by Chief U.S. District Judge Troy L. Nunley to 30 years in prison for wire fraud, concealment money laundering, and witness tampering in connection with a $35 million investment fraud scheme, U.S. Attorney Eric Grant announced.

On May 15, 2025, four days before trial, Piercey pleaded guilty without a written plea agreement to 27 counts charged in the indictment.

"Today's sentence reflects the devastating human toll of this fraud scheme," said U.S. Attorney Grant. "Piercey preyed on trusting investors, many of whom he met at church, convincing them to hand over decades' worth of savings. The losses are measured not only in dollars but also in shattered futures and other personal hardship for families. This prosecution demonstrates our commitment to holding accountable those who enrich themselves through deception."

"Matthew Piercey made complicated but empty promises that his investment advice would guarantee profits. He also had a detailed plan to avoid prosecution," said FBI Sacramento Special Agent in Charge Sid Patel. "He greatly underestimated the skill and determination of the FBI agents, forensic accountants, and specialists, who carefully unraveled his web of lies and stopped his attempt to escape arrest. The FBI will continue to go after anyone who takes advantage of investors for personal gain."

According to court documents, between July 2015 and August 2020, Piercey solicited investor funds by holding himself out as an investment advisor through his purported investment companies Family Wealth Legacy and Zolla. He made a variety of false and misleading statements to investors about the nature and success of trading algorithms, commissions and fees, investment strategies, the liquidity of investments, and the financial stability of Family Wealth Legacy and Zolla. For example, Piercey marketed the "Upvesting Fund," an automated algorithmic trading fund that he falsely claimed had a history of success. He took money from numerous investors in this purported fund but privately admitted to an associate that there was no Upvesting Fund.

Running a Ponzi-like fraud scheme, Piercey used some investor money to make payments to other investors. As the scheme progressed, Piercey used a Redding-area chiropractor to conceal his continued operation of the investment fraud and take in new money.

In total, Piercey paid back only approximately $8.8 million to investors of the approximately $35 million invested. He used the additional money for various business and personal expenses, including paying a criminal defense firm and buying two residential properties. Few, if any, liquid assets remained to repay investors.

According to court documents, when Piercey learned he was under investigation, he took steps to dissuade investors and witnesses from responding to grand jury subpoenas. His actions caused several individuals to delay producing documents, while at the same time, he syphoned off nearly $775,000 from victim investors into a bank account he controlled.

On Nov. 16, 2020, when law enforcement agents attempted to arrest Piercey, he fled from arrest and led agents on a vehicle chase through residential neighborhoods and onto the highway before abandoning his vehicle and entering Lake Shasta with an underwater submersible device. After about 20 minutes in the water, he emerged from the lake where he was arrested.

After his arrest, Piercey used coded language to communicate with two individuals who visited him in jail. He directed these individuals to take actions with the contents of a U-Haul storage locker he had rented in Redding. A subsequent FBI search of the storage locker revealed that Piercey had rented the locker under a fictitious name, Chadwick Givens, using a fake California driver's license. The locker contained, among other things, a wig and ₣31,000 in Swiss francs.

The Federal Bureau of Investigation conducted the investigation. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Matthew Thuesen, Audrey B. Hemesath, and Kevin Khasigian prosecuted the case.

Kenneth Winton, 73, of Chico, who conspired with Piercey in the scheme, pleaded guilty in December 2020 and is scheduled for sentencing on Aug. 27, 2026.