11/20/2026 | News release | Distributed by Public on 11/20/2026 12:31
Members of the public have until 11:59 p.m. (EST) on Monday, November 23, to submit comments to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission regarding a petition for rulemaking (PRM) that proposes changes to the way irradiated fuel reprocessing plants are regulated.
If the updates that the petition suggests are accepted, fuel reprocessing facilities that handle quantities of strategic special nuclear material (SSNM) large enough to support commercial production would be required to follow the same material control and accounting (MC&A) requirements as other nuclear fuel facilities not covered by an exception. The effect would be a tightening of the regulations that govern reprocessing plants, compared with those currently in effect.
Members of the public can submit their comments on the PRM at Regulations.gov by searching for docket ID NRC-2026-4456.
What the petition proposes: Howard L. Hall, professor and director of the Institute for Nuclear Security at the University of Tennessee-Knoxville, submitted the PRM on August 17. In the petition, Hall requests that the NRC amend 10 CFR Part 74, specifically section 74.51(a) under Subpart E, so that fuel reprocessing plants are no longer excluded from that part of the rule. This would mean that reprocessing facilities must adhere to the five MC&A standards as stated by the rule:
Along with suggesting that reprocessing plants be subject to these criteria, Hall's petition requests additions to Subpart E of 10 CFR Part 74 that would cover the bulk chemical processing that occurs in reprocessing plants, which differs from the processes in conventional fuel fabrication plants. It also asks to clarify the regulatory requirements for research and pilot-scale facilities that might possess less SSNM than a commercial production facility.
Should the NRC decide not to amend Subpart E, Hall's PRM provides an alternative course of action: to add a new subpart to 10 CFR Part 74 that would establish regulatory requirements specific to reprocessing facilities equivalent to what he has suggested for Subpart E.
Why the PRM was submitted: In his PRM, Hall notes that when 10 CFR Part 74 was adopted in 1987, and again when it was amended in 2002, fuel reprocessing was not considered a commercially viable activity. The NRC therefore left open the question of whether a fuel reprocessing plant could meet the regulatory requirements for a Category I fuel facility, which is authorized to handle SSNM in an amount known as a formula quantity.
Instead, reprocessing plants were addressed under a different section of the rule, 10 CFR 74.41(a), which regulates facilities that handle special nuclear material "of moderate strategic significance"-a quantity less than a formula quantity. In comments accompanying the 1987 rule, the NRC stated that if reprocessing became viable, it was open to revisiting the regulations governing reprocessing facilities in a way that allowed MC&A requirements to align with the technology in place at the time.
That time has arrived, according to Hall. His PRM cites several factors that have changed the momentum behind reprocessing, including the issuing of Executive Order 14299 in May 2025 (which calls for the development of fuel recycling and reprocessing technologies), the Department of Energy's pursuit of the Nuclear Lifecycle Innovation Campuses initiative, and proposals from private entities to build recycling plants. In Hall's own words, the previous dire outlook for commercial reprocessing "no longer describes the situation before the agency."
An outside expert's assessment: Jenifer Shafer, professor at the Colorado School of Mines and former program director at the Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy (ARPA-E), largely agrees with Hall's assessment of the current state of commercial reprocessing in the United States. In response to questions from Nuclear News, Shafer expressed a belief that the foundations for commercial reprocessing could be laid this decade, saying, "A licensed commercial-scale plant is a plausible 2030s outcome."
Shafer provided three reasons for stating that the outlook for commercial reprocessing is stronger now than it was in 1987 or 2002:
Additionally, Shafer sees a compelling case for bringing reprocessing plants under the requirements of 10 CFR 74.51(a). "The 2002 rule explicitly deferred reprocessing-specific requirements. Addressing them now would give applicants greater predictability, bring domestic requirements into closer alignment with international safeguards practice, and establish early expectations for process monitoring and near-real-time accountancy," she said.
However, Shafer cautions that applying bulk processing provisions to Subpart E comes with a risk that the provisions will be written strictly to cover PUREX, the established technology. Her suggestion: "[The] NRC should define performance objectives that applicants can meet across different process chemistries and plant designs."
She also offered a final consideration as fuel reprocessing advances: "Congress should fund NNSA [National Nuclear Security Administration] research and development on material accountancy for non-aqueous and non-separating flowsheets. Developing and validating measurement methods alongside the recycling processes themselves would give applicants and NRC staff a stronger technical basis for designing and evaluating safeguards. It would also give the United States an opportunity to lead in both fuel recycling and the measurement science needed to safeguard it."