Certified Collectibles Group LLC

11/17/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/17/2026 08:07

Counterfeit Detection: Morgan Dollars with Added Mintmarks

Here is a tale of two alterations: one carefully executed and the other… not so much.

To outwit a counterfeiter, it helps to think like one. Scroll through the Morgan Dollars section of the NGC Price Guide and take note of the difference in price between the Philadelphia issues with no mintmark and the issues of the same date that do have a mintmark (indicating they are from branch mints). There are many opportunities for an unscrupulous person to add a mintmark to a Morgan to try to make an ill-gotten profit of hundreds or perhaps even thousands of dollars.

The 1902-dated Morgans are one such example. In low Mint State, a 1902 from Philadelphia (with no mintmark) has a price guide value of about $200. Meanwhile, a 1902-S from San Francisco (with the 'S' mintmark) is worth about $700. NGC recently examined a purported 1902-S that was included in a submission.

Because of the potential for added mintmarks, a great place to start when examining a 1902-S Morgan is the mintmark area, which is found on the reverse above the 'DO' in DOLLAR. Seen in the middle image below, it is clear there are multiple red flags with this mintmark.

For starters, there is a glaring discoloration that is localized to the mintmark itself and the immediate area around it. This was caused by the adhesive applied to the area to glue the 'S' to a mintmark-less Morgan. (Assuming the counterfeiter had been careful enough not to get any adhesive on the front of the mintmark itself, they probably noticed it had seeped out from the back and stained the surrounding area. Subsequently applying the adhesive to the mintmark would at least make the discoloration more uniform. Remember, a mintmark like this is smaller than a grain of rice, so this is delicate work.)

There is a second issue that also identifies this as an added mintmark. Note the size and shape of the 'S' itself in the middle image when compared to the genuine 1902-S at left. At the bottom left of the 'S' in the center image, there is a sharp downturn in the serif - a detail that is missing on the genuine 1902.

In fact, the added mintmark here looks much closer to the mintmark typically found on an 1880/79-S of the VAM-9 Large S variety. Examples of this variety can be found in low Mint State for less than $200, so the counterfeiter still has plenty of room for a profit. Keep in mind that a counterfeiter doesn't even need a Mint State coin, so long as the mintmark itself is in decent shape. (And, after harvesting the mintmark, the counterfeiter could potentially sell the rest of the silver in the donor coin for scrap, an important consideration since silver prices have tripled over the past three years.)

Not all added mintmarks are this easy to spot. Consider the purported 1892-S Morgan above, which arrived at the NGC Grading Room around the same time as the altered 1902-S. A genuine 1892-S in low Mint State is worth tens of thousands of dollars, compared to just a few hundred for an 1892 without a mintmark! Clearly, there is potential here for a large payday for a counterfeiter.

Though it lacks the obvious signs that were seen on the 1902 coin, NGC's experts ultimately determined this Morgan also had an added mintmark thanks to an important clue on the obverse. The 1892-S Morgan Dollar has been extensively studied by experts, and none of the 16 sets of dies used to strike them has its date in a position that matches the one on this coin. Therefore, it becomes clear that the 'S' was added.

The submitters of the purported 1902-S and 1892-S Morgans in this column were well-advised to send them to NGC, which backs its determinations of authenticity and grade with the NGC Guarantee.

Did you know? NGC has created a comprehensive Counterfeit Detection resource to help collectors and dealers identify counterfeit and altered coins. Visit NGCcoin.com/counterfeit.

Certified Collectibles Group LLC published this content on November 17, 2026, and is solely responsible for the information contained herein. Distributed via Public Technologies (PUBT), unedited and unaltered, on November 17, 2026 at 14:07 UTC. If you believe the information included in the content is inaccurate or outdated and requires editing or removal, please contact us at [email protected]