11/18/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/18/2026 13:57
WASHINGTON-Subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement Chairman Clay Higgins (R-La.) delivered opening remarks at today's hearing on "Oversight of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives' Out-of-Business Records Retention Practices." In his statement, Subcommittee Chairman Higgins raised concerns that the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives' (ATF) record retention process could eventually become a national firearms registry, threatening lawful firearm owners' Second Amendment rights. He also highlighted how ATF's new proposed rule that would limit firearm dealers' sales records retention requirements to 20 or 30 years could create loopholes for establishing a lifetime national firearms registry.
Below are Subcommittee Chairman Higgins's opening remarks as delivered:
Welcome to today's hearing of the Subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement.
Today, we are examining a collection of records most Americans have never heard of: more than 1.4 billion firearm sales records held by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.
When someone buys a gun from a licensed dealer, they fill out a federal form with their name, address, and date of birth, along with the gun's make, model, and serial number.
When a dealer closes without a successor, federal law requires that those records go to ATF.
And ATF keeps them indefinitely.
In Fiscal Year 2025, ATF took in roughly 6.8 million new records per month.
Federal law forbids the creation of a national gun registry.
This is to protect the Second Amendment rights of all Americans from being infringed by any future tyrannical government engaged in firearm confiscation.
Federal law thus bars ATF from creating any system to register firearms, gun owners, or gun sales.
It bars ATF from consolidating dealers' records.
And it bars ATF from electronically searching out-of-business records by name or any other personal identifier.
ATF says it follows those rules. It says the records are pulled only to trace guns recovered by police as a result of a crime.
And the Government Accountability Office has found that the system does not currently cross the line into a registry. That's the opinion of GAO.
So ATF's Out of Business Records Imaging System, or OBRAS, is an existent digital record, a massive digital record. When out-of-business records are scanned, a buyer's name can be captured as searchable data.
Searching by name is a function that ATF has simply "turned off" to remain compliant with federal law. It could just as easily be turned on.
Think about that. The difference between this database and an illegal national gun registry may come down to a software setting that ATF itself controls.
These records do have some law enforcement value, of course. I'm well aware. Tracing a gun used in a crime to its first retail buyer might give investigators a lead, and out-of-business records were used in nearly half of the crime gun traces ATF handled in 2022 and 2023.
2023. I can say from personal experience and observation that the impact on local and state law enforcement, crime investigation is almost nonexistent in these records, but nonetheless, a lead in a criminal investigation is not a conviction and a prosecution.
And ATF cannot say whether any given trace led to a successful prosecution. It doesn't track that.
And the older a gun is, the more likely it has changed hands. That's generally always the case. By the time a gun is recovered on a crime scene, the odds that that gun still belongs to its original owner is very slim. Perhaps it's changed hands multiple times on the secondary market where no records are kept.
That brings us to ATF's recent proposed rulemaking on records retention. There has never before been a cap on how long ATF is allowed to retain out-of-business dealer records. The rule for dealers has swung back and forth.
Prior to 1985, dealers were required to retain their sales records indefinitely. After 1985, a new ATF rule limited the requirement to 20 years. That 20-year mark generally settled in as acceptable across the board for a dealer to maintain records. This rule was again changed in 2022 under the Biden Administration, which again required indefinite retention.
This year, ATF proposed a new rule which would limit to either 20 or 30 years the sale records retention requirement for dealers and, for the first time, cap at either 20 or 30 years-how long ATF itself is allowed to keep those records.
Some see that as a step in the right direction. I'm not necessarily one of those people. But those two clocks, those two 30-year clocks can stack. A record could sit with a dealer for 30 years, and then if that dealer goes out of business without a successor, [could] sit with ATF for another 30 years. That is 60 years on file for a law-abiding American's name, address, and gun purchase data.
And what [is] more significant, perhaps-that's 30 Congresses. And we see what can happen with the way the pendulum swings in America from one Congress to the next, the variance of laws. And what we seek today in today's hearing is just [to] objectively put the truth on the table for the American people to consider. We have Second Amendment rights to protect, and we have an obligation to do so.
So, the question before us is not whether law enforcement should have the lawful tools it needs to solve gun crimes, of course. We support that.
But our observation, based upon accurate historical data for a long time, is that this this record retention is precariously close to an illegal federal registry. And with one push of a button, [it] could become quite a tool of oppression against American people, whereas the benefit for law enforcement is almost nonexistent.
The question before us is whether a collection this large, reaching back this far-60 years-is worth the risk to law-abiding Americans' privacy and the risk that a gun registry would erode the Second Amendment's guarantee that the right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.
With today's hearing, we hope to weigh the principled Second Amendment concerns around ATF's records retention practices against federal law enforcement's interest in holding those records for some period of time.
We are honored to have expert witnesses with us today to help examine this important issue.