What Does Five Below’s Falling Multiple Really Say

For questions about this article or underlying research, email [email protected].

Five Below (FIVE) shareholders know the usual rule: a lower price-to-earnings multiple, or what investors pay for each dollar of profit, means a cheaper stock. Three years ago, Five Below traded at 33 times its profit over the previous twelve months. At the October 27, 2026 close, it traded at 20.6 times. Does a multiple that has fallen this far make Five Below a cheaper stock?

Five Below Stock Rose While Its Multiple Fell

Five Below's share price rose 43.7% between late September 2023 and October 27, 2026. The multiple came down over those same three years, so investors paid more for each share but less for each dollar of profit behind it.

How Much Has Five Below's Profit Grown?

Five Below earned $619 million in profit over the latest twelve months, compared with $272 million three years earlier. That is 2.3 times as much profit. Nearly all of the rise came in the latest year, following two years where profit barely moved.

The company's stores sell toys, games, snacks and home goods. Leisure, its largest segment, brought in 44.5% of revenue in the fiscal year to January 2026, ahead of Fashion and home. On its September 2, 2026 call, management said sales in the latest quarter grew because sales at existing stores rose 14% and the store count rose about 9%. Management added that pricing and lower tariff costs lifted gross margin in that quarter.

Does A Lower Multiple Make Five Below Cheaper?

Not by itself. The question worth asking is what buyers were paying for when the multiple stood high, and whether they got it. At the end of 2021, Five Below's multiple reached 44.1, its highest in the past five years. Profit today is about 2.4 times what it was then.

Buyers paid the most for each dollar of profit when there was far less of it, expecting it to grow. It did, though the growth took until the latest year to show up. This traces the usual curve for a growing company's multiple: high while profit is small, lower once the profit arrives. Five Below navigated a bumpier path, however. Its multiple fell to 17.3 in 2024, when profit had barely moved, and climbed back to 31.2 in 2025.

A buyer today does pay less for each dollar of Five Below's profit than a buyer three years ago did. But that earlier buyer was paying for growth that had not happened yet, and it has now happened. Today's lower multiple is mostly what Five Below looks like after the growth arrived, not a discount. Part of the latest profit, though, came from tariff refunds that management leaves out of its adjusted results.

Where Is Five Below On That Curve Now?

Five Below is now in the stage where the profit has arrived, and its profit growth has sped up. Following a 2.9% drop the year before, profit rose 126.8% in the latest twelve months. Profit grew far faster than sales, which rose 25.6%. In the latest quarter alone, management's adjusted profit, which leaves out the refunds, more than doubled to $93 million, while reported profit was $221 million.

On reported profit, which includes the tariff refunds, the multiple sits a little below the S&P 500's 22.6. Take out the $128 million gap between reported and adjusted profit in the latest quarter, and it rises to about 26, above the index. The figure to watch is how fast Five Below's profit grows with the tariff refunds left out, starting with its next report, expected in December 2026.

Sitting On A Big Gain In Five Below?

After a run like this, the hard questions are personal: hold, trim or sell, and the tax on each. Our partner advisory firm offers a free strategy review of ways to keep part of the upside, protect the rest and spread the tax over years.

Request A Free Strategy Review

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.