What Changed In Procter & Gamble’s Story

For questions about this article or underlying research, email [email protected].

Procter & Gamble (PG) stock trades at 22.9 times its earnings over the past twelve months, placing it close to the 22.6 for the S&P 500. Shareholders paying that price need to know what they are buying, and the costs management discusses have changed over time. In July 2025, executives emphasized what tariffs would cost the company. By the October 22, 2026 call, the focus had moved to a different expense, one management first raised on calls earlier in 2026. So what cost is management talking about now?

Procter & Gamble Now Emphasizes Commodity Costs

Management now emphasizes the higher cost of raw materials, energy and freight. During the fiscal Q1 2027 call, executives tied these expenses primarily to the conflict in the Middle East. The company's fiscal 2027 outlook includes a cost headwind of about $1.4 billion after tax from these expenses. That estimate assumes Brent crude oil at an effective $100 a barrel.

In July 2025, that cost was tariffs. During the fiscal Q4 2025 call, management stated its outlook included $1 billion before tax in higher costs from tariffs.

Tariffs still came up on the October 22 call, but in a different context. Management said the company received about $90 million in the quarter as the second part of a tariff refund, while also listing tariffs among the disruptions its guidance does not assume. The topic now surfaces on earnings calls as a refund and as a risk, while commodity expenses have become the cost management talks about.

How Does The New Cost Compare With Tariffs?

The commodity cost is the larger of the two. Management's $1.4 billion estimate for fiscal 2027 is an after-tax figure, yet it still tops the $1 billion before-tax projection placed on tariffs in July 2025. That tariff estimate was for fiscal 2026. Weighed against overall profits, that $1.4 billion compares with net income of $16.0 billion over the twelve months to September 2026.

Management's estimate of the hit is also rising. The company placed the combined hit from input costs, currency and items below operating profit, such as higher interest, at 11% of fiscal 2026 core earnings per share. That estimate is up from 8% on the July 2026 call. Management expects these headwinds to increase in the next few quarters, anticipating materially higher costs in fiscal Q2 2027.

Missed opportunity happens to all companies. See how Tesla was affected in How Tesla Blundered.

Should Procter & Gamble Holders Worry About Commodity Costs?

The change looks more concerning than reassuring for a holder, as management said the new costs already weighed on the latest quarter. Gross margin was 49.8% in fiscal Q1 2027, down from 51.4% a year earlier. Management stated that commodity and freight costs, along with spending to build demand, offset the company's productivity savings in the quarter.

Sales are holding up so far. Revenue rose 4.0% from a year earlier in fiscal Q1 2027, with management reporting that each of the 10 product categories grew organic sales. The company also kept its fiscal 2027 guidance ranges for organic sales, core EPS and free cash flow productivity.

Gross margin is the number to watch when Procter & Gamble reports fiscal Q2 2027 results, expected in January 2027.

Paid In Procter & Gamble Stock?

Many readers of a Procter & Gamble article work there and own its stock through grants or a purchase plan. When your paycheck and your savings depend on the same company, one bad year can hit both. Our partner advisory firm offers a free strategy review of ways to protect a large company-stock position and sell it down with less tax.

Request A Free Strategy Review

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.