03/31/2026 | Press release | Archived content
There's no shortage of herbal supplements that claim to support your immune system. But when you have a chronic autoimmune condition like lupus, certain natural ingredients could end up doing more harm than good, suggests a major new review published in BMJ Lupus Science & Medicine.
"Herbal supplements are not regulated the same way that medications are," says Cassandra Dolecki, Pharm.D., a member of the Lupus Foundation of America's Medical-Scientific Advisory Council and a clinical pharmacy specialist with Allegheny Health Network in Pittsburgh, who was not involved in the study but who reviewed its results. "It's important to better understand these supplements and how they can impact autoimmune diseases, because there may be risks that could be particularly harmful to people living with lupus," she says.
Hear what life with a health condition actually looks like. Now in one app. Built for people living with chronic and rare conditions.
Researchers from the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine in Philadelphia reviewed data from 469 studies that investigated the immune-stimulating properties of more than 200 herbs. Seventy-nine of the papers were human studies, 145 were model organism studies (meaning, they involved non-human subjects like mice or fruit flies), and 148 were test tube studies.
The analysis found robust evidence that 15 of the herbs have clear immunostimulatory effects. In other words, they increase immune system activity in the body. Some of the studies also showed a direct link between the herbs and an uptick in flares for skin-related autoimmune diseases like lupus and dermatomyositis (a chronic autoimmune disease that causes progressive muscle weakness and rashes).
The herbs with these properties included:
Alfalfa
Ashwagandha
Astragalus
Chlorella
Echinacea
Garlic
Ginseng
Green tea extract
Indian mulberry
Licorice
Mistletoe
Reishi mushroom
Skullcap
Spirulina
Tinospora
These herbs, which are often found in products touting immune support, were tied to mechanisms that ramp up inflammation in the body. Some were shown to boost the production of inflammatory proteins like cytokines, while others activated immune pathways that are also involved in lupus and dermatomyositis inflammation.
Translation: These substances have the potential to add more inflammatory fuel to the fire for health conditions that already cause excessive inflammation. "My takeaway is that many commonly used supplements can exacerbate autoimmune diseases, and caution should be exercised when considering their use," Dolecki says.
Autoimmune conditions like lupus and dermatomyositis are both marked by an overactive immune system. The overactivity causes the immune system to mistakenly attack parts of the body (often the skin and joints for lupus, and the skin and muscles for dermatomyositis), causing inflammation and symptoms like rashes, fatigue, joint pain, and muscle weakness.
Throw in an herbal supplement that causes an additional surge in immune system activity and it's easy to see how you might end up with harder-to-manage symptoms or a flare. "With immune-boosting herbs, they're basically inducing proteins that can help the body fight off infection. That's why some people take [the herbs] when they're getting a cold," explains Victoria Werth, M.D., one of the study's coauthors and a professor of dermatology at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. "But in a setting where a person's immune cells are already overactive [like with lupus or dermatomyositis], the herbs are stimulating the immune cells to be even more active."
And while this review didn't look at the effects on treatment, it's entirely possible that immune-boosting herbs could end up messing with your prescribed therapies. "Treatment for lupus is generally aimed at calming down the immune system or changing how the immune system responds to the person's own cells, so these supplements may cause lupus medicines to be less effective," Dolecki points out.
We'll need more research to have a better understand of exactly how individual herbs impact diseases like lupus and dermatomyositis. But there's more than enough evidence to encourage that people with either condition be ultra careful with herbal supplements, say Dr. Werth and Dolecki. That's the case whether a product's ingredient list includes one of these 15 herbs or not. Supplements are only loosely regulated, and they're often mislabeled, research shows. So you can't always trust that a product actually contains what's listed on the package (and is free of anything else).
The bottom line? "Just because a supplement is marketed as 'natural' does not mean that it is safe, especially for people living with lupus," Dolecki warns. So, make sure your doctor knows about any supplements you're currently taking, and get their okay before adding anything new to the mix. "Lupus can already be difficult to manage with currently available treatment options, and the challenges unique to a person with lupus must be strongly considered before deciding to take an herbal supplement," she adds.
Herbs Review: BMJ Lupus Science & Medicine. (2025.) "Identifying immunostimulatory herbal supplements that may flare autoimmune skin diseases: a systematic scoping review." https://lupus.bmj.com/content/12/2/e001803
Mislabeled Supplements: Frontiers in Sports and Active Living. (2023.) "Prevalence of adulteration in dietary supplements and recommendations for safe supplement practices in sport." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10570429/