Pittsburgh Woman Sentenced for Vandalizing Jewish Properties

PITTSBURGH, Pa. - A resident of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, has been sentenced in federal court to five years of probation on her conviction of conspiracy to commit an offense against the United States and defacing and damaging a religious building, Acting United States Attorney Troy Rivetti announced today.

United States District Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand imposed the sentence on Talya A. Lubit, 25.

According to information presented to the Court, Lubit and her codefendant, Mohamad Hamad, conspired to damage and deface the Chabad of Squirrel Hill. The Chabad is a center for Jewish educational programming and occupies a building for Jewish religious services in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh. In the early morning hours of July 29, 2024, acting on their plan to cause damage to a Jewish institution, Lubit and Hamad spray-painted the words "Jews 4 Palestine" with an inverted triangle onto the exterior of the Chabad building with red paint. The inverted triangle first appeared in videos posted online by Hamas, a designated foreign terrorist organization, of the current fighting in Gaza, where the symbol was used to mark an Israeli target about to be attacked by Hamas fighters. The act of vandalism was born from Hamad's and Lubit's shared growing animosity towards Israel since the terrorist attack of October 7, 2023, and the war that ensued between Israel and Hamas.

Charges against Lubit's codefendant Hamad, which also include making false statements in a matter within the jurisdiction of the Executive branch of the United States and possession of destructive devices, remain pending.

As part of her sentence, Lubit agreed to pay restitution of $10,534 for the damage done to the Chabad property, as well as graffiti that she and Hamad spray-painted on an entry sign to the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh the same day.

The sentencing hearing included the reading of victim impact statements from both Chabad of Squirrel Hill and the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh regarding the impact the defendants' vandalism had on their institutions and community. Chabad of Squirrel Hill described the damage of the spray-painting as "not only physical but deeply symbolic" and "a painful reminder that we remain a target," with the incident having "caused distress and fear among our members." The Jewish Federation stated that "the hateful words and symbols painted on our Federation sign revived deep feelings of fear, violation and vulnerability" and that the vandalism's "premeditated nature based on our remote location made it clear that the target was not just property, but our employees."

"Talya Lubit instilled fear in the Pittsburgh Jewish community by spray-painting a synagogue with the mark of a designated foreign terrorist organization, along with vandalizing the sign of a building belonging to an organization that provides critical services to members of the Jewish community and others," said Acting United States Attorney Rivetti. "Protected speech obviously does not include damaging or defacing religious property, and our office will continue to work with our law enforcement partners to protect the civil rights of all members of our community to practice their faiths and to live without fear."

Assistant United States Attorney Carolyn J. Bloch prosecuted this case on behalf of the government.

Acting United States Attorney Rivetti commended the Federal Bureau of Investigation and Pittsburgh Bureau of Police for the investigation leading to the successful prosecution of Lubit.