Insight Guru Inc.

11/20/2026 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 11/20/2026 02:59

How Low Could Circle Stock Go

Today's big story: Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks?

Circle stock closed at $51.88 on Thursday. That is 80% below its June 2025 peak of $263. It is only 3% above its February low of $50.23. Here we ask what could push it lower.

Circle's profit depends mostly on one number. That number is the dollars held in USDC, Circle's stablecoin, a digital token tied to the dollar. At today's rates, every $10 billion of USDC is worth about $10 a share. Part 1 explains how that works: Circle Stock At $52: What Would It Take To Get To $90? Here we look at three ways that link could break, and what each would cost.

The short answer: if USDC stops growing, the stock is worth about $16. If USDC shrinks by a fifth, earnings disappear. That would be under half of its 2023 fall. The floor would then be Circle's book value, about $14 a share. In our view, today's price assumes neither happens.

Circle's stock is already 80% below its peak, and the bad cases put it lower still. If you would rather wait for a lower price before you buy, your cash can earn something while you wait. The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3 times the S&P 500's, from 50 companies that have paid dividends for at least 10 years in a row. See what it pays.

What If USDC Shrinks?

It already has, three times. USDC shrank 45% in 2023. That was after Silicon Valley Bank failed while holding more than $3 billion of Circle's deposits. Circle's average USDC fell 39% that year. Its share of dollar stablecoins went from 34% to 20%. Over that time, Tether "increased while the amount of USDC in circulation declined for nearly a one year period."

In 2026 it slipped again, from $77.0 billion in March to $73.9 billion in September. Since Sep 30, the daily data shows USDC down another 7%, to $68.9 billion. All dollar stablecoins fell 6% over the same time.

Period USDC Change
2023 $44.6B to $24.4B -45%
Mar to Sep 2026 $77.0B to $73.9B -4%
Sep 30 to Nov 18, 2026 $74.4B to $68.9B -7%

Source: year-end and quarter-end figures from Circle's filings. The last row is daily market value from CoinGecko via the Trefis platform, which runs about 0.7% above Circle's own count.

What it costs: the $5.5 billion lost since September takes about $6 off the share's value. Say USDC falls another 20% from here, under half of 2023's fall. With costs on their current path, Circle would then earn almost nothing.

What If Interest Rates Fall?

Circle has measured this one itself. Each 1 percentage point drop in rates cuts its yearly interest by $739 million. It also saves $371 million of payouts to partners such as Coinbase. The net loss is about $368 million before tax. That is about $1.03 a share of earnings, or $26 of stock price at today's multiple.

This has already happened. In the third quarter, Circle's yield was 0.61 points lower than a year earlier. That cost it $106.5 million of interest in three months, more than USDC's growth added. The 3-month T-bill, a short-term US government bond, now pays 4.34%. A return to the third quarter's lower rates would undo the lift Circle is getting now.

What If Circle Keeps Less Of The Interest?

The slice Circle keeps depends on where USDC sits. USDC held on Coinbase pays most of its interest to Coinbase. Coinbase's slice of all USDC rose from about 5% in 2022 to 20% in 2024. Circle kept 38% of its interest in 2026. If that slips to 33%, base-case earnings in 2028 fall from $1.99 to $1.44 a share. That takes about $14 off the stock. The offset is Circle's own platform, where its slice rose to 18.1% from 13.5%.

How Low Could The Stock Go?

Put together, the three risks give a range and a floor. The table shows the bad cases in 2028, two years out, with costs on their current path. When earnings nearly vanish, a multiple of earnings stops meaning much. Investors then fall back on book value, what the company owns minus what it owes. For Circle, that is $3.9 billion of equity, about $14 a share.

Case, 2028 Earnings a share Value a share
Base: USDC +20%/yr, rates hold $1.99 ~$50
Base growth, rates -1 point $0.87 ~$22
USDC flat, rates hold $0.65 ~$16
USDC -20% (under half of 2023's fall) ~$0 book, ~$14

Source: Trefis, using the same chain and assumptions as part 1. Reserves earn 3.9%, or 2.9% after a 1-point cut. Circle keeps 38%. Other revenue is $250 million. Costs are about $1.11 billion in 2028, from about $1.0 billion over the last four quarters. Tax is 25%. There are 268 million shares, valued at 25x earnings. Book value is Circle's equity on Sep 30, 2026.

Costs are the lever Circle controls. Each $100 million it doesn't spend adds about $0.28 a share of earnings. That is about $7 of value. In our view, a Circle facing a flat USDC would likely cut. That softens the bad cases. It doesn't change their direction.

What Would Stop The Fall?

The same thing that drives the upside: share. There are real signs that more people are using USDC. 7.3 million wallets hold $10 or more of it, up 16%. Onchain transactions in USDC, payments recorded on the blockchain, rose 49% to $13.9 trillion last quarter.

But balances are what pay Circle. Last quarter, new USDC grew 31%, while redemptions, USDC turned back into dollars, grew 54%. In our view, until that flips, the risk is to the downside.

The line to remember: Circle's downside comes down to three numbers you can track. They are USDC's supply, the T-bill rate and how much USDC sits on Coinbase. A flat USDC is worth about $16 a share. A fall of a fifth or more leaves about $14, its book value. Size a position so either one is survivable.

A stock that can fall this far is hard to sit through. That is easier when the rest of what you own tends to drop less than the market.

Could You Hold On Through The Next Fall?

Holding on is easier when your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average, holding 30 quality stocks in equal weight.

See How HQ Held Up

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email [email protected].

Insight Guru Inc. published this content on November 20, 2026, and is solely responsible for the information contained herein. Distributed via Public Technologies (PUBT), unedited and unaltered, on November 20, 2026 at 08:59 UTC. If you believe the information included in the content is inaccurate or outdated and requires editing or removal, please contact us at [email protected]